Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] You're listening to the Oklahoma Memo podcast, the fastest way to get smart on Oklahoma news, politics, business, and sports. Welcome to the Oklahoma Memo podcast. 0:17 My name is Ryan Welton, the founder and curator of Oklahoma Memo. It's a daily local news recap that hits your inbox six days a week at 7:00 AM. Sign up at oklahomamemo.com/subscribe. 0:28 And this is the Oklahoma Memo podcast, and today we're talking with my good buddy, Scott Mitchell, political analyst for Griffin Media. That means News 9 and News On 6. 0:37 And today, Scott, we are talking about some news that happened very late in the week. You know, you have the Friday news dump. There was some big news to come out of Comanche County. 0:48 It's pretty incredible when Judge Shepard, 0:52 I- I'm not sure precisely, Thursday, Friday, whenever this, this judgment came down or this ruling came down, but it's the culmination of a hearing that was done almost a week ago in Comanche County by 1:05 the co-counsel to the attorney general, the Whittenburg's law firm, which attorney general has made them co-counsel in this case against State Farm. 1:13 Remember, Ryan, that he's also named Allstate, but we're not seeing, have not seen any, uh, any courtroom action on that one yet. 1:22 And it's drinking from a fire hose because my interview with him earlier this week, I think Tuesday, he said he's gonna name a third company. 1:30 But this was a hearing, this, this ano- uh, the West family, I believe, in Comanche County. So the ju- they had in front of them, "Can we depose the CEO about this alleged hail wind scheme?" Okay? 1:44 You don't see CEOs getting deposed very often, okay? This is like out of a Grisham book, okay? Right. I, I think The Rainmaker comes to mind. [laughs] Mm-hmm. Okay? So anyway, that was about who... 1:58 And, and they were being, State Farm, being ably represented by, um, uh, Tim Larother, who is, uh, with, uh, McAfee Taft, or Crowe & Dunlevy, I believe, one of the big firms. 2:10 And the judge earlier, I think maybe a week ago, couple days after the hearing, said, "Nope, CEO's gotta set for deposition." So all right, goes back in your chair on that one. 2:23 And I listened to that, that discussion, and I've been going to the courtroom on these since probably last April or May. Um, the basic, uh, gist was, "No, he, this person's gotta have to be deposed." 2:37 Now, there's limits in the deposition. They just can't go in there and ask 100 jillion questions, but he- Mm. The CEO's gonna be deposed. The bigger one was these, this alleged hail wind scheme. Now, 2:51 can I give you a real quick background on that? Yeah, yeah. Ple- please do. There's been a lot in Oklahoma Memo, um, and of course, uh, our, uh, friend, J.C. 2:59 Holman, has done a ton of reporting on this, and I think I understand the basics of it, but yeah, let's reset for everybody. Well, I, I have to do this every time I get ready to do this story. 3:09 Holman, by the way, if he doesn't win a Pulitzer or a couple on this, then there ain't no justice in this world. He's become the Bob Woodward of the State Farm stories. Mm-hmm. I digress. 3:20 The second issue was, can these documents be unsealed that purport to show a scheme? In insurance, in generally speaking, in insurance, 3:31 the rules are something happens to your roof, an adjuster has to go out and make an estimate, and then you decide what, what is gonna happen on the claims. 3:42 What the plaintiffs have alleged was that State Farm's like, "Nah, we're gonna just, no matter what, we're cutting claims by X amount," like sometimes 50%. That's against the law. That's against the rules. 3:55 And the blockbuster was a few months ago, Attorney General, Attorney General Drummond jumps in and says, "I wanna, I wanna intervene in this case. People are getting ripped off." 4:05 Now, that is the time w- when we started seeing the media go, "What is going on here?" Right. 4:13 And especially when Gentner Drummond said he was going to apply civil RICO, Racketeering Influenced Corrupt Organization. Now, when you say... RICO was created to get the mafia. Right. Okay? 4:29 And u- usually, usually it's criminal and not civil, right? That is correct, but- And didn't... Hmm... I, I don't wanna jump ahead of you, but Tuesday when I interviewed the attorney general, 4:42 he said he had read these documents. He makes Whittenburg his co-counsel, so he has ac- ac- uh, access to these documents, but as he said, and I'm... You may have the clip of this. He said, "I'm bound by the same rules. 4:57 I can't unseal these. I, I can't go public with these." That was 96 hours ago. The world has changed. And I asked him, I said, "Have you seen the documents?" He goes, "Yes." 5:07 I said, "Do you understand why State Farm is fighting so hard to keep these secret?" He goes, "Yes." And he said, "I've seen the emails with the CEO," and he said, "Uh, it's practically indictable." 5:24 Uh, now, this is the chief law officer of the state of Oklahoma, okay? Mm-hmm. So Thursday, Friday of this week, Judge Shepard in the Comanche County Court said, "Unsealed," and the world has changed. 5:40 So before, on the record, before yesterday, we're taping Saturday, before yesterday, we have both J- Gentner Drummond, and July the 22nd, we have former Senator Mike Mazie 5:55 laying out how they feel about the State Farm issue. We're, what, 72 hours from the opening of polls? And Mr. Maisey, in his interview with Jonathan Cooper, was pretty darn clear he thought this was 6:13 a, a political stunt. Well, we're, we're gonna... I'm assuming the media's gonna find him Monday morning, because what these documents show, just, just a cursory read, is it weren't no stunt. Right. 6:28 I mean, this is a real scheme, and you've even... I even read one document from a State Farm agent going, writing to them going, "What are y'all doing? You're not paying claims. 6:41 We know that there's something going on here. You're losing your reputation. We're worse..." [laughs] This is what they got. Yeah. "You're worse than Allstate." [laughs] Just excoriating- Yeah... State Farm. 6:51 And then it lays out what the, what the plan was, how much they were cutting, and bragging in one document, "Oh, we saved $1.8 billion." Now, what's been happening to rates? Through the roof. And, [scoffs] 7:07 you know, we've seen the commissioner here go, "Well, it's, it's, we're getting more wind and hail." Ryan, this blows it up. Okay? This, this... 7:16 It's almost like now, now we've gotta sit down and figure this one out, because 7:21 some people, including the commissioner, Senator Maisey, are gonna have to recalibrate where they're at, because these documents provide in stark relief that this was indeed a, I'll use this word, a plan 7:36 to cut payouts, no ifs, ands, or buts. And can I ask you a question here? 7:40 Because it sounds like what the plan is is that they just set for the entire company, "Our plan for 2026 is to have 52% fewer payouts," and then it's up to the agencies to sort of, like, hit that mark? 7:57 There were, there were... One of the documents said, "This is the big bucket." Let's... A quote, "The big bucket. This is the big opportunity. We're paying out too much in claims." 8:06 You're supposed to, according to rules of fairness, you're supposed to be paying out claims based upon the damage that you see. Right. Okay? 8:14 Instead, this looks like it was planned in advance, and this is what the attorney general and the plaintiffs, Witt and Burrage, have been saying. That this was a plan, this was... 8:25 We're making profits and not playing by the rules. Mm-hmm. That's what this whole thing has been about, and these documents a- appear from... 8:34 And when you just read plain language, it appears that there was a plan to do this. They're bragging on how much money they saved, and it's, this is tough. And Ryan, you're in front of the line here, okay? 8:47 Because it's going to take... All over this town right now, there are editorial, uh, staffs thinking about Monday morning. Mm-hmm. Every print operation, every broadcast operation is gonna, 9:03 uh, enjoy your weekend off, because Monday morning, which will be, when they start having those meetings, that's less than 24 hours before- Right... the polls open. And this is, 9:15 I'm gonna assume that the last 24 hours, this is all you're gonna hear about. Right. Especially in the gubernatorial race, and perhaps in the insurance commissioner race. Mm-hmm. 9:24 You've done a number of interviews so far for, uh, Griffin Media. What, what from those have stood out? The, the, the stark difference between Senator Maisey and Gentner Drummond on this issue. 9:40 Right, and it's, uh, just as simple as they have stark different opinions about it. Uh- Yeah... there are, you know, um, even in the insurance commissioner race, we have a difference. 9:53 The, Bob Sullivan and the two others who were in the primary, uh, they, they said, "Yeah, uh, people ought to be able to legally sue their carriers," whereas, uh, Marty Quinn was for tort reform, which is just code for that we individuals shouldn't be able to sue our carriers. 10:11 It should be handled by legislators who know better. Do I have that right? Yeah, the, the commiss- uh, Mr. 10:18 Quinn, who ha- is a friend of the current commissioner, I mean, they've, uh, done fundrai- uh, former Commissioner, uh, Doak has done fundraisers for Marty. He's a really nice guy. Mm-hmm. 10:28 Like, I did a long interview with Marty Quinn, and he's like, "The commissioner can be tougher." I mean, he, he wouldn't, didn't take a shot at Mulready, but he was like, "Man, we, we can do a lot better job on this. 10:38 We can intervene." Mm-hmm. Here's what the bottom line is. Advocating for tort reform, like Senator Quinn and Senator Maisey, if it wasn't for [laughs] the ability of the plaintiffs to sue, 10:55 State Farm would still have these documents hid out- Mm-hmm... and we wouldn't know the truth. That's- Yeah, so-... that's the issue... for, for Oklahomans, average, average Joes and Janes out there, understand this. 11:06 I know, I get it, that there are a lot of you who you just don't like lawyers, but here's the fact. This is a great example of a case where they are actually fighting for you, for the public good, to try to get these... 11:21 It's not that they're trying to get the rates down. All anybody wants is for the insurance companies to play fair when a hailstorm passes through and destroys your car, or you get roof damage. 11:32 I mean, the case that, the first one that JC wrote about was the Hirsch family out of Broken Arrow, and it's just, uh, and there have been many more since. 11:41 It's funny how when one person comes forward, that, uh, courage becomes contagious. Uh, it, it is, and [scoffs] this is a pretty good... I don't know what's gonna happen next. 11:54 I mean, I haven't spent two minutes thinking about what's next. Um, we do know that Judge Palumbo is... Look, I was, I've watched, I've been in the courtroom, in Judge Palumbo's courtroom and now s- uh, Judge Shepherd. 12:08 These people were exasperated with State Farm.... the legal team of State Farm. They were just, Judge Palumbo has made this order. She's ready to unseal documents. 12:18 She's even going to start sitting in on depositions, she's so angry with the way the State Farm attorneys were dragging their feet. This isn't, I'm not being, I'm, this is not shading it one bit. 12:31 I've watched the anger- Right... visible anger with Judge Palumbo, and I've seen her lecture these lawyers. Yeah. This has been... 12:40 I asked the attorney general the other day, "Can you see why State Farm wanted, doesn't want these documents out there?" Now we know, okay? Right. Now we know. 12:48 And if the Hershes and the West didn't have the opportunity to sue, we would not know the truth. That's right. 12:55 And that, at the end of the day, okay, screams against limiting the ability to sue, and it really puts Senator Quinn and Senator Maisy behind the eight ball. 13:05 As I said earlier today, some on some interview, I said, "They got some explaining to do." Right. Right, right, right. Yeah. It's g- gonna be very interesting. 13:15 And, uh, you know, what I'm gonna try to do, and I know what, uh, you're doing, uh, with Griffin, is make that 285-page PDF available to folks. 13:23 Um, I know we're both looking through it right now, trying to, to parse out what these exhibits say and what it all means, and to make sense of it. 13:31 I mean, that's the goal of Oklahoma Memo, ultimately, is to try to take complicated issues and put it in as plain an English as possible. There's o- only in my r- my time reporting, 13:47 the two biggest issues, and I actually worked in the tobacco settlement, was watching... I- if you want, you old-timers, if you want to g- go back and watch The Insider, Al Pacino, Russell Crowe- Good movie... 13:57 right, about the tobacco settlements, okay- Mm-hmm... and those documents. Those documents, I, here's a modern equivalent, the Epstein files. 14:05 I mean, if you want to see the, all the court, uh, jumping around, people not wanting these files out there. Now, 14:13 if you were to ask me what advice I would give right now to the folks that said, "Well, we need more tort reform," and I'm taking, I'm, I'm not gonna throw rocks at State Farm. My, run from them. 14:24 I mean, S- [laughs] Senator Maisy and Senator Quinn could look at it and go, "Well, he, we had no idea that this sort of behavior was going on." Run, do- run, don't walk. Right. Okay? This, this is now, if this were... 14:41 The, the main thing in terms of an issue like damage control for Senator Maisy and Senator Quinn would be that people don't find out about it a- until it's, the, uh, primary's over. Right. 14:52 Senator Quinn's and, uh, and, uh, Senator Maisy, they haven't done anything wrong. Right. They're just like everybody else. They didn't know what was in these documents. Right. Right, right. 15:01 And they- They probably lied too, too... [laughs] they, they coincidentally have an opinion about tort reform. Yeah. And maybe, I mean, everybody has the chance to change their mind. 15:09 Maybe they'll look at this and say, "Ooh." Somebody thought parking the planes wing tip to wing tip at Pearl Harbor was a good idea. [laughs] You know what I'm saying? Yeah. You, we can't know. 15:25 And I think that's, I, I don't want to draw, people to draw the wrong conclusion. 15:30 People who were doing the tort reform side and maybe saying, you know, "Wait, let's not throw rocks at State Farm and, and these other ones that are coming," th- they didn't know. I- Mm-hmm... 15:41 we didn't know what was in these documents. I, but Gentner Drummond and Reggie Whitten and others were telling people what was, that this was going on, and guess what? Total and complete vindication. Right. 15:53 Joined here by Scott Mitchell, political analyst with Griffin Media News 9 and News on 6. 15:58 So, uh, Monday morning, the folks at, in mainstream media, in their editorial meetings, um, you know, what, what do you think their plan of action is going to be to try to break all this down? 16:10 'Cause I'm gonna have this video up tonight, and we've already done a pretty good job of it. Uh, well, that's why you're Ryan Wiltern. Thanks. [laughs] And [laughs] I would say, you know, you're better... 16:22 This is the new reality in media. Y- you know, if you don't move fast, then you lose. Right. Speed kills, right? Right. Um, Monday morning. 16:32 I asked, um, somebody recently, I can't remember, it wasn't on the, on this topic. Uh, what are you gonna do on day one? Oh wait, it was the attorney general, and we're talking about education reform. Mm-hmm. 16:42 He said, "Uh, the mistake people make is they wait until they're sworn into office. You gotta move now." And my advice to media would be move in now. Right. 16:50 I do know that, that I've heard there are already some interviews being, uh, planned right now. So people are moving. This thing could spread like wildfire. 16:59 I thought that the issue that was going, the viral issue that was gonna happen at the end was going to be the financial disclosures and the medical disclosures. Uh, you know, that hasn't happened. Right. 17:12 And frankly, I don't think that media did a very good job of following up on that from the debate two weeks ago. That, that's a big issue. It's happening all over the country, but I digress. You're right. 17:23 This is the big issue. And we've seen the president of the United States poo-poo affordability to his detriment and the Republican Party's detriment, okay? Mm-hmm. When you're at 30% approval rating and you're seeing 17:40 the Democrats elect s- uh, socialist Democrats- Right... as your nominee- Right... okay, you, you've done screwed this up, okay? Affordability is real, and you can put your head in the sand. 17:52 Well, homeowner rates and gasoline prices are real, and this is one of them. And this could, look, I don't want to be overly dramatic, this could tilt the balance in both of these races. The- Right... 18:07 the governor race and the insurance commissioner race. It could, it could be a, um, a real issue in the general election too Yeah. I, I would, you know, I, I did that interview with, uh, Ginter Drummond the other day. 18:20 I offered the same time. Un- s- you know, no debates, just open and de- uh, discussion, say whatever you want with Senator Mazie. He declined. He also declined an, I believe, a, a Griffin interview the other day. 18:37 I appreciate w- that there is a campaign strategy. Man, you better have a 15-point lead if you don't address this one. Right. Right. 18:46 Well, uh, Scott, I appreciate you explaining this and helping me understand it, as well as the Oklahoma Memo audience. 18:54 Uh, if you have questions about this, if you have comments, I will make sure that these get to Scott, and we'll get these answered as soon as possible. Scott, anything else you'd like to add before we wrap? 19:05 I'm glad you understand it because [laughs] it's... I'll tell you what I, the, the one thing I, I would add is I'm gonna spend two minutes. The fascinating story, Ryan, is going to be what's next. Right. I agree. 19:17 I agree. Yeah, to the extent that I understand it. You know, it's like- I don't know if we're gonna, State Farm's gonna start settling this stuff. You know- Right... 19:24 there was a bunch of cases early on that got settled for enormous amounts, way, way over damages, right? Right. And that's been one of those that's like the media was having difficulty. 19:37 Well, it's because people knew what was in these documents as it turns out. Right. The s- the documents were the key. 19:43 I also, when I was in Lawton, by the way, I would just, just one quick addition, there was a national network down there. Hmm. Which one, do you remember? Do you guys... NBC. NBC. 19:54 Yeah, NBC Nightly News was down there in that courtroom. Mm-hmm. I believe there will be other attorneys general around this country, this story's gonna go viral- Right... 20:05 in the news media, and you may be an attorney ge- you know, American Association of Attorneys General, I've always thought that stood for American As- Association of Aspiring Governors. [laughs] Right. 20:19 But I think attorneys general all over this nation- Yeah... are going to be, "What's happening over there?" Right. And Ginter Drummond has said, "If I win, I'm taking this to the governor's office." 20:32 I, I don't know how it would affect either Mr. Coffee or Mr. Echols, but nonetheless, if this, listen, if this happens, right now the worst thing that could happen to State Farm is a Ginter Drummond win on Tuesday. 20:45 Mm-hmm. That would be no bueno for that company. Yep. There you have it. Scott Mitchell, political analyst, Griffin Media, News 9, News on 6. [coughs] Good to see you, pal. Good to see you, man. 20:56 We need to do this more often. Uh, leave a comment below if you got a question for Scott or myself. Until next time, we will talk to you later.